Editorial Guidelines
Our commitment to honest, helpful, and authentic restaurant reviews that serve Halifax diners and the local food community.
Core Principles
Independence
We maintain complete editorial independence. All meals are paid for by HFX Eats, and we never accept free meals, gifts, or compensation that could influence our reviews.
Authenticity
Every review reflects genuine dining experiences. We visit restaurants as regular customers and base our opinions on multiple visits when possible.
Constructive Feedback
Our reviews aim to be helpful to both diners and restaurants. We provide specific, actionable feedback while celebrating what makes Halifax's food scene special.
Review Process
Initial Visit
We visit restaurants as regular customers, making reservations under personal names. We never identify ourselves as reviewers during the dining experience.
Documentation
We take detailed notes during and immediately after each visit, documenting food quality, service, atmosphere, and value. Photos are taken discreetly when appropriate.
Multiple Visits
For comprehensive reviews, we aim for multiple visits at different times and days to ensure consistency. Single-visit reviews are clearly noted.
Writing & Review
Reviews are written within 48 hours of the final visit while memories are fresh. Each review undergoes editorial review for accuracy, fairness, and clarity.
Rating System
Exceptional
Outstanding in every aspect. A destination restaurant that defines Halifax dining excellence.
Excellent
Highly recommended with minor flaws. Consistently delivers great experiences.
Good
Solid choice with some standout elements. Worth visiting with realistic expectations.
Fair
Has potential but significant issues prevent recommendation. May improve with time.
Poor
Fundamental problems that significantly impact the dining experience. Not recommended.
What We Do & Don't Do
We Do
- Pay for all meals and experiences
- Visit restaurants multiple times when possible
- Consider context (new restaurants, off nights, etc.)
- Update reviews when restaurants make significant changes
- Highlight local sourcing and sustainability efforts
We Don't Do
- Accept free meals or compensation
- Review restaurants based on single bad experiences
- Make personal attacks on staff or owners
- Review restaurants during their first week of operation
- Use AI-generated content or stock photos
Corrections & Updates
We strive for accuracy in all our reviews. If you notice an error or if a restaurant has made significant changes since our review, please contact us at hello@hfxeats.com. We will investigate and update our content as appropriate.
All corrections and significant updates are noted at the bottom of reviews with timestamps for transparency.